PARSEES AND THE SATYAGRAHA IN SOUTH AFRICA
E. S. Reddy
There were less than fifty Parsee families in South Africa when the Indian community launched the passive resistance (satyagraha) of 1906-14, first in the Transvaal and later mainly in the Natal. But they contributed some of the most determined and eminent satyagrahis. Gandhi chose one of them to act as his successor in South Africa.
The contribution of Parsees is particularly significant as they were relatively prosperous and enjoyed special privileges in South Africa. They were treated like Europeans in the Transvaal, until the Asiatic Registration Act came into force in 1907.1
1 When Gandhi took his wife and children to South Africa for the first time in 1896, he decided that they should adopt the Parsi style of dress to look "civilised". "Accordingly my wife wore the Parsi sari, and the boys the Parsi coat and trousers." M. K. Gandhi, My Experiments with Truth, Chapter 55.
2 Indian Opinion, January 16, February 20 and July 3, 1909
When Gandhi was desperate for funds to support the indigent resisters and their families, it was a Parsee, Sir Ratan Tata, who helped by sending him three large donations of 25,000 rupees each. And J. B. Petit, joint secretary of South African Indian Passive Resistance Fund in Bombay, was collecting funds in India to meet the needs of the struggle.
It is also a significant coincidence that two persons most helpful in Britain to the Indian community in South Africa were Parsees: Dadabhai Naoroji, a Liberal Party member of Parliament for a term; and Sir Muncherjee Merwanjee Bhownaggree, from the Unionist Party, who was a member of Parliament for over ten years.
Gandhi developed a special feeling for the Parsees because of his association with them, especially during the Satyagraha. Five of the Parsees who participated in the resistance deserve special recognition and their short biographies are given below.
Nadirshah Ardeshir Cama2
Mr. Cama was born in Bombay in 1870. After passing the Intermediate Examination of the University of Bombay, he worked in the Bombay Port Trust from 1891 to 1895. He went to Durban in 1895 and worked for a few months with Messrs. Dada Abdulla & Co. He moved to Johannesburg early in 1896 and obtained a position in the Post Office. Unlike many other Indians, he remained in the Transvaal during the Anglo-Boer War of 1899-1902.
He joined the British Indian Association founded by Gandhi in 1903 and became a member of the executive in 1906. He took a prominent part in the passive resistance struggle against the Asiatic Registration Act, denounced by the Indian community as the “Black Act”. That law, enacted in 1907, required Asians – there were also Chinese miners in the Transvaal - to obtain registration certificates by giving ten thumb impressions. Any male over 16 who failed to produce the certificate on demand by the police or other officials was liable to arrest and deportation from the Colony.
This was not only an imposition on Indians who had already twice obtained permits to reside in the Transvaal. It was similar to the pass laws hated by the Africans and the Criminal Tribes Act in India.
Mr. Cama, a fluent speaker, often denounced the actions of the government against the Indian community. He was dismissed from his job as postmaster at the end of 1907 as he refused to register under the Black Act and arrested in January 1908. On 27 January he was ordered to leave the Transvaal within fourteen days.
At the end of January, however, an agreement was reached between Gandhi and General Smuts, the Minister of the Interior. All satyagrahis were released from prison and pending cases dropped. Mr. Cama was reinstated in his old position.
Under the agreement the Indian community agreed to register voluntarily. Gandhi understood that, in return, the government would repeal the Black Act. General Smuts denied that he had promised the repeal of the Act and further negotiations failed to result in a satisfactory agreement.
The Indian community burnt the registration certificates and resumed the satyagraha in the second half of the year. Mr. Cama was active in organising resistance and was again dismissed from his job in September 1908.
He was arrested on 17 February 1909 for failing to produce a certificate of registration under the Black Act and sentenced to three months with hard labour. In June, soon after his release, the Indian community elected him as a member of a delegation to India to make representations about the treatment of Indians in the Transvaal. The government arrested him and charged him again with the same offence, thereby preventing him from undertaking the mission. He served another term of imprisonment with hard labour.
Mr. Cama was married, and had five children, the youngest of whom was born whilst he was serving his last sentence.
He continued his public activities after the Satyagraha ended in 1914. He was elected Vice-President of the Transvaal Indian Congress and attended the Amritsar Congress of the Indian National Congress in 1919 as a delegate from South Africa. In the same year, when further anti-Indian legislation was under consideration, he joined other leaders of the Transvaal Indian Congress in pledging to resist any law which imposes class distinction or disability upon Indians and “to suffer, undergo and endure every consequence which such disobedience to the civil laws may entail.”3. He was elected a member of the council of the South African Indian Congress at its inaugural session in 1923.
3 Young India, 27 August 1919
4 N.A. Cama was a partner in this firm.
5 Indian Opinion, 11 and 18 July and 19 September 1908; 13 February and 23 October 1909; 4 and 11 June 1910; 17 and 24 June 1911; 10 March 1912.
Mr. Cama’s brother, Ardeshir Framji Cama, of A.F. Cama & Co.,4 was also arrested in February 1909 and served a term in prison.
Mr. Shapurji was born in Adajan, India. He belonged to a well-known Parsi family in Bombay and was a cousin of Parsee Rustomjee, a loyal friend of Gandhi. He was a bookkeeper and manager of the store of a Muslim merchant in Charlestown, Natal.
The Indian community wanted to test the Immigration Restriction Act by inviting an educated Indian to cross the border into the Transvaal to claim the right to residence under that Act, while refusing to register under the Asiatic Registration Act. Several young Indians volunteered, and Sorabji was chosen by a committee. He entered the Transvaal on 24 June 1908, with testimonials from the Chairman of the Charlestown Local Board and other prominent Europeans, and went to stay with N. A. Cama in Johannesburg. He had a British passport valid for all of Africa. He was brought to Court on 8 July and was ordered on 10 July to leave the Colony within seven days.
He told the Court that he had received 14 years of education, seven of them through the medium of English. He had been in Durban for a year and a half and in Charlestown for four-and-a-half years. He had made an application for voluntary registration in the Transvaal, but he had never applied for registration under the Asiatic Act, “an un-British and disgraceful Act”.
He defied the order to leave the Transvaal and was sentenced to a month's imprisonment with hard labour. Released on 19 August, he was deported to the Volksrust border after a day's solitary confinement and pushed on to the Natal border.
Several educated persons followed him by crossing the border, and claiming the right of residence in the Transvaal, refusing to give thumb impressions under the Black Act, and going to prison.
Sorabji was deported and recrossed the border again and again, served sentences of imprisonment with hard labour. He was sentenced to three months in September 1908, six months in February 1909, three months in June 1909, six months in October 1909, three months in June 1910, and three months in November 1910. He was imprisoned seven times and served the longest in Transvaal prisons when Gandhi and Smuts reached a provisional settlement in 1911 and the satyagraha in the Transvaal was suspended.
He then went to India and attended the session of the Indian National Congress in Calcutta in 1912. At a farewell meeting in Durban on 16 June, Gandhi said:
“As a satyagrahi Mr. Sorabji has displayed many fine qualities. He has rightly been described as the greatest of the satyagrahis… To be sure, Mr. Sorabji stands out from the rest because he volunteered for suffering. He came from Natal and was the first from that Colony to join the campaign. Complaints were frequently made against the satyagrahis in gaol, but never against Mr. Sorabji, He is by nature, a mild and amiable person. That cannot be said even of Mr. Thambi Naidoo. No improper word was ever heard to escape his mouth. He has none of the Parsis’ faults but I have found in him all their finer qualities. Though so well endowed he is without a trace of pride. Though a Parsi, he is an Indian first. Hindus, Muslims and Christians alike admire him. That he continues firm on his course, having once set it, and that he tries to understand every issue, is his fourth virtue. Mr. Sorabji is without compeer.”
Gandhi had great hopes that Sorabji would be a worthy successor to him, when he left South Africa, to serve the Indian community. He sent him to London to qualify as a barrister, choosing him for a scholarship offered by Dr. Pranjivan Mehta. After being called to the bar in London, Sorabji returned to Johannesburg, practised law and performed public work. But he passed away on 13 July 1918.
Gandhi wrote in an obituary on July 27, 1918: 6
6 Letter to the Press by M. K. Gandhi on July 27, 1918, published in Bombay Chronicle, July 29, 1918. From Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Volume 14, pages 507-08.
“One of the best Indians has just passed away in Johannesburg in the person of Sorabji Shapurji of Adajan, near Surat, at the age of thirty-five. And it is my mournful duty to pay a humble tribute to a fellow-worker. Mr. Sorabji, though known to a select company of friends, was unknown to the Indian public. His work lay in South Africa. He was a prince among passive resisters. He joined their ranks when the struggle in South Africa was at its highest and when it had travelled beyond the confines of the Transvaal. When he joined the struggle, I must confess, I had my doubts about his ability to go through it. But he soon made his mark as a front-rank satyagrahi. Neither he nor I ever expected that he would have to undergo a series of imprisonments amounting in all to over 18 months with hard labour. But he went through it manfully and cheerfully. Mr. Sorabji was a small trader when he took to public life in South Africa. He had a high school education. But such as it was, he made the most effective use of it in the Transvaal. During the struggle, he showed a steadfastness of purpose, probity of character, coolness of temper, courage in the midst of adverse circumstances, such as the best of us do not often show. There were occasions when the stoutest hearts might have broken - Sorabji never wavered…
“The deceased took an active part in all the leading movements among Indians in London. He was for some time Secretary of the London Indian Society. He was the first to join the Indian Ambulance Corps that was formed in London at the inauguration of the war and served at Netley, nursing the sick and the wounded. After being called to the Bar, he proceeded to South Africa, where he intended to practise the profession and return to India after he had given a number of years to South Africa and found a substitute. But alas! fate has willed it otherwise and a career full of promise had to come to an abrupt end.”
Gandhi devoted a whole chapter of Satyagraha in South Africa to Sorabji.
Shapurji Jivanji Randeria7
7 Indian Opinion, 15 and 29 August and 12 September 1908; 13 March and 11 September 1909
Born at Rander in the Surat district in India in 1880, S. J. Randeria arrived in South Africa in 1900. He had passed the senior book-keeping examinations of the London Chamber of Commerce in Bombay. After arriving in Durban he founded a customs clearing and shipping business. He had a passport issued to him by the British Consul in Zanzibar entitling him to proceed to any British Colony with all rights of British citizenship.
He crossed the Natal-Transvaal border in August 1908, along with Parsee Rustomjee and others, to claim his right as an educated person to enter the Transvaal. He was arrested on 27 August and the next day the Court ordered his deportation to Natal. He re-entered the Transvaal and was arrested again. He told the Court that, as a Parsee, he had been granted a permit such as was issued to Europeans under the Peace Preservation Ordinance. He could not submit to a degrading Act like the Asiatic Act. South Africa was the land of his adoption and he claimed the right to reside anywhere therein.
He served three terms in prison, totalling twelve months, with hard labour. He was sentenced to three months with hard labour in September 1908 and to a similar term after release. Released on 4 March 1909, he was rearrested the next day and sentenced to six months with hard labour. He was arrested again on the day of release and deported to Charlestown. He had to proceed to Durban from there because of his brother’s serious illness.
He was a respected community leader in Natal in later years. Ismail Meer wrote in his memoirs:
“I remember Shapurji Randeria as that imposing quiet man, who was the Gujarati examiner at the Pine Street Madressa and as the person of so many sterling qualities”.8
He passed away in September 1945.
8 From Ismail Meer’s memoirs in The Leader, Durban, August 28, 1987. See also Dhanee Bramdaw (ed.) The South African Indian Who’s Who and Commercial Directory, 1936-37. The Natal Witness, Limited, Pietermaritzburg, 1935.
Rustomjee Jiwanji Ghorkhodu (Parsi Rustomji) 9
9 Indian Opinion, 15 August and 12 September 1908; 13 February, 14 August and 11 December 1909; 19 February 1910; 1 and 8 October and 24 December 1913. Dictionary of South African Biography. Published for the Human Sciences Research Council by Tafelberg-Uitgewers Ltd., Pretoria, 1987. Volume V. Also "In the Early Days with Gandhi" in Illustrated Weekly of India, Bombay October 3, 10, 17 and 31, 1965
Rustomjee was born in India in August 1861 and arrived in Durban at the age of seventeen. He worked in an aerated waters company and later became a prosperous businessmen. He was commonly known as “Parsi Rustomjee” (or “Kakaji”). He was one of the founders of the Natal Indian Congress on August 22, 1894, and was elected its Vice-President.
Gandhi came to know him soon after his arrival in South Africa and a close bond developed between them. He sheltered Gandhi and his family on January 13, 1897, when Gandhi was attacked by a European mob on his return from India. The whites threatened to burn down Rustomjee’s house and property, but he was not deterred.
In August 1908, together with Dawad Mahomed, N. C. Anglia, Shapurji Randeria and others, he crossed into the Transvaal by train to test his domiciliary rights in the Transvaal under the Immigration Restriction Act and assist the struggle of the Transvaal Indians against the Asiatic Registration Act. They were arrested in Pretoria on 27 August and the next day ordered to leave the Colony. They recrossed the border and were sentenced to three months with hard labour.
Parsee Rustomjee said in his evidence before the Court in Volksrust that he was a general merchant in Natal where he had large bu